Log in

Login to your account

Username *
Password *
Remember Me

Create an account

Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.
Name *
Username *
Password *
Verify password *
Email *
Verify email *
Captcha *

Latest News

Madeleine McCann: German prisoner identified as new suspect in disappearance

Madeleine McCann: German prisoner identified as new suspect in disappearance

A 43-year-old German prisoner who travelled around Portugal in a camper van is now the focus of...

Algarve tourism experts predict 30% occupancy over this summer

Algarve tourism experts predict 30% occupancy over this summer

"Any dialogue you have with travel agents and hoteliers in the Algarve, if we think about June,...

Loulé Council shoots down Vilamoura lake city mega-project

Loulé Council shoots down Vilamoura lake city mega-project

The Environmental Impact Study of the lake city mega-project in Vilamoura has received an "unfavorable opinion" by...

‘Whoever enters Portugal should test negative’, defends local MP as tourism floodgates reopen

‘Whoever enters Portugal should test negative’, defends local MP as tourism floodgates reopen

Cristóvão Norte, an Algarvian MP for the Social Democratic Party (PSD) has defended that "there must be...

Arab sheik-owned Algarve hotel workers strike over lack of pay dating back to March

Arab sheik-owned Algarve hotel workers strike over lack of pay dating back to March

Local workers at the JJW Hotels Resorts Group, owned by Sheikh Mohamed Bin Issa Al...

Algarve orange producers see unexpected rise in business, safe from pandemic economic uncertainty

Algarve orange producers see unexpected rise in business, safe from pandemic economic uncertainty

The COVID-19 pandemic unexpectedly benefited the Algarve citrus industry with an increase in demand and prices, which...

The show goes on as theatres and cinemas reopen warily across Portugal

The show goes on as theatres and cinemas reopen warily across Portugal

Theatres, cinemas and other cultural venues across the country got the go-ahead to reopen this Monday as...

‘High risk of widespread wildfires across Europe’ this year, says EU crisis commissioner

‘High risk of widespread wildfires across Europe’ this year, says EU crisis commissioner

The European Union expects dry weather to cause unusually widespread wildfires in Europe over the coming months,...

Latest Features

Art and Photography news from the Algarve - June 2020

Art and Photography news from the Algarve - June 2020

Welcome to our June 2020 Newsletter. Another month has passed and things seem a little brighter here on the Algarve now. CLICK...

Gale's Virtual Westminster View – May 2020

Gale's Virtual Westminster View – May 2020

May. Too many Cummings but no Goings. Thousands wait for package holiday refunds as the travel industry goes into meltdown. The Home Office does...

Studio Bongard are relocating after 22 years!

Studio Bongard are relocating after 22 years!

It is with a little sadness that at the end of June this year Tara and Sylvain Bongard will leave their studio space of...

AlgarvePLUS Magazine - June 2020

AlgarvePLUS Magazine - June 2020

Welcome to the June issue of AlgarvePLUS magazine. The hazy summer days are here, with just a bit more freedom than in previous months....

How an ESA Provides the Comfort and Companionship You Need

How an ESA Provides the Comfort and Companionship You Need

A stressful lifestyle or an innate condition can lead to feelings of anxiety, depression, mental fatigue, and even suicidal thoughts. Naturally, this can significantly...

Euro surges on EU’s Next Generation plan optimism

Euro surges on EU’s Next Generation plan optimism

Staying on top of the latest currency news can help you time your transfers more effectively, so find out what you should be looking...

Algarve Archaeological Association on hold for the Summer

Algarve Archaeological Association on hold for the Summer

The AAA lecture which was due to be held on Tuesday 2nd June has been cancelled due to the current situation with the Coronavirus....

Welcome to the low touch economy!

Welcome to the low touch economy!

Since early March, expressions like social distancing, pandemic, quarantine and isolation have begun to be part of our lives and of our daily conversations....

Tourism Post-CV19

Tourism Post-CV19

Tourism is one of the sectors most affected by Covid-19. The UN-World Tourism Organization issued rules for Sustainable Tourism:

Brexit and Fiscal Representation in Portugal

Brexit and Fiscal Representation in Portugal

After three years of uncertainty the UK has now left the EU! How will this affect UK residents that have assets in Portugal? Since...

Germans prove €6.4 million submarine bribe was received by four Portuguese elite

submarineThe 2004 purchase of two submarines from a German consortium that includied Ferrostaal, was eased through by the payment of €6.4 million in bribes to establishment figures in Portugal.

People linked to the PSD/CDS-PP government and to the Portuguese Navy received €1.6 million each to ‘facilitate business’ with the German submarine consortium.

The submarine scandal goes back to 2004 when the then Defence Minister Paulo Portas* authorised the €900 million deal. 'Der Spiegel' magazine reports that all the 'stakeholders' in the business received the same bribe of €1.6 million.

In addition to the four Portuguese figures there is Jürgen Adolff, the former Honorary Consul of Portugal in Munich, who was convicted in March 2014 and sentenced to a two year suspended sentence.

The bribes were in return for arranging a meeting between a director of Ferrostaal and the then Prime Minister, Barroso.

A statement from a manager of Erbslöh, a subsidiary of Ferrostaal, outlined how the submarine bribery system worked, a system until 2000 that was so open that the company was able to claim the sums paid to foreign government employees as a legitimate business expense when it came to its end-of-year accounts.

After 2000, shell companies were set up and used to conceal and channel the bribes to the right people.

According to the German magazine 'Der Spiegel', searches at Ferrostall’s head office have revealed more than a dozen contracts intended to disguise the payment of kickbacks to “decision makers in the government, in the ministries and in the Portugal Navy."

The Public Prosecutor's Office in Germany continues to investigate suspicions related to the creation of a series of shell companies used for the payment of illegal commissions in the submarine case.

In December 2014, the Portuguese public prosecutor dropped the case, saying that proving the payments were received was too hard a task.

Defendants Helder Battaglia dos Santos, Luis and Miguel Horta e Costa, and Pedro Ferreira Neto walked free as if nothing had happened. This was despite the German authorities already giving suspended sentences and fines to two Ferrostall directors for sending the bribes to the Portuguese decision makers.

According to the Germans, several companies have been identified as being used to handle bribes, as have some of the Portuguese people involved, hopefully all of them.

In 2006, Rear Admiral Rogério d'Oliveira received €1 million via one of these shell companies. D’Oliveira already had retired and was acting as a representative for the German company in Portugal. He was never charged.

In addition to the retired Rear Admiral, people now named as being involved in the financial transactions are Helder Bataglia dos Santos, from Grupo Espírito Santo (GES), Luis Horta e Costa, the former president of ESCOM, the GES company that advised the German consortium, Miguel Horta e Costa, the former president of PT, and the lawyer Vasco Vieira de Almeida.

The German authorities now are able to describe and name the series of fictitious companies which handled the bribes including GES, both in the UK and in the US Virgin Islands. This is good progress indeed and a big embarrassment to the Portuguese prosecution service which simply gave up.

Portugal’s filing of 18 volumes of evidence covering eight years of work containing interviews, diagrams, a complete chronology of the facts, references to ministers’ council resolutions, emails between the parties, contract terms and memos was a sad reflection on a highly politicised legal system that ensured the correct result was arrived at.

The Germans have proved that bribes were paid: the Portuguese failed to find out which of its citizens received the money. Only due to the continuing efforts of the German prosecutors are the facts being revealed and the Portuguese names about to be revealed.

Whether proof of receiving bribes will be enough to reopen the shelved case in Portugal remains to be seen but the public interest must be served and those who profited from the overpriced sale of German submarines must be held to account.

 ________

* Paulo Portas has never properly explained how and why officials at the national headquarters of the CDS-PP in December 2004 went to a Banco Espírito Santo branch in Lisbon and paid in €1,060,000 in cash into the party’s account.

In just four days, 105 cash deposits were made for amounts always less than the anti-corruption alert limit.

Those amounts were justified as ‘donations collected at parties and dinners which had been stored in the vaults of the national headquarters.’

There were 4,216 receipts which noted only the amount and the donor's name, a list that the Judicial Police said was clearly fictitious.

__________

For the case background, see:

http://www.algarvedailynews.com/cases/submarine-case

Pin It

Comments  

+1 #5 Christian 2016-08-02 15:02
"Jürgen Adolff, the former Honorary Consul of Portugal in Munich, who was convicted in March 2014 and sentenced to a two year suspended sentence."
How I wish that this meant he was hung upside down in his underpants from Munich Town Hall's balcony and left hanging there for two years...
+4 #4 Peter Booker 2016-08-02 14:48
I agree with Poor Portugésa that Barroso must have known what was going on; and he probably played his part in the hush-up. Is it too much to hope that, now that he has left the EU Commission, and has joined Goldman Sachs, his influence has waned? It may also be that António Costa (PS) will put the boot in to his predecessors (PSD-PP). But I am not holding my breath.
+6 #3 Poor Portugésa 2016-08-02 12:07
'The EU and the ECB should make their agreement to further financial support conditional on the successful prosecution of the recipients of these bribes' - wishful thinking? Barroso was also the EC's head honcho for years, we'll never forget.
Peter is more likely to see some satisfaction in Germany - we can hope..
+17 #2 Ben 2016-08-02 09:14
"In December 2014, the Portuguese public prosecutor dropped the case". Yet another example of how rotten and corrupt the elite of this country are.
+17 #1 Peter Booker 2016-08-02 08:13
How can it not be true that the Portuguese Public Prosecutor has been instructed to archive this case? As the Germans have now given names to the recipients of some of the €6.4m, will the case be re-opened in Portugal? Somehow, I doubt it, even though the case is clearly still live in Germany.

Perhaps the EU and the ECB should make their agreement to further financial support conditional on the successful prosecution of the recipients of these bribes.

Or if we examine the US model of prosecution of FIFA officials, the fact that wrongdoing took place on US soil, and with US dollars, was sufficient for USA to extradite South and North American football officials from Europe. As some of the submarine bribery happened with German money and on German soil, should the Germans copy that lead, and take over the prosecution themselves of the Portuguese recipients of bribes?

You must be a registered user to make comments.
Please register here to post your comments.

Property

Coronavirus Impact on the Algarve Housing Market

Coronavirus Impact on the Algarve Housing Market

Many people are wondering what has happened to the housing market in the Algarve during these extraordinary times effecting the...

Surge in user traffic from European countries suggests interest for holiday making, according to Imovirtual

Surge in user traffic from European countries suggests interest for holiday making, according to Imovirtual

Portugal started to ease lockdown measures from Monday 4th May with a three phase plan to reopen the country’s economy....

Fine & Country Get Back To Business (not quite) As Usual

Fine & Country Get Back To Business (not quite) As Usual

Portugal has begun a partial relaxation of lockdown regulations from Monday May 4th, with many businesses allowed to return to...

Exclusive Algarve Villas - April 2020 Newsletter

Exclusive Algarve Villas - April 2020 Newsletter

Welcome to our April newsletter! With businesses in lock down (locally we’re now at 2 months), we can see some...

What's Happening?

West Coast Car Boot Sale Set to Return In July

West Coast Car Boot Sale Set to Return In July

The West Coast Car Boot Sale, normally held on the first Sunday of each month, will not be taking place in June. Hopefully it will be able to start again...

Latest Classifieds

We are direct providers of Fresh Cut BG, SBLC and MTN
(Services / Offered)

We are direct providers of Fresh Cut BG, SBLC and MTN

Seat Ibiza Station A/C
(Vehicles / Cars)

Seat Ibiza Station A/C

ERRANDS & SERVICES
(Services / Offered)

noimage

Minivan
(Vehicles / Other)

Minivan

Subscribe

Want to be kept up to date? Subscribe to our regular E-Newsletter here.
* Please use a valid email address, as a confirmation email will be sent.