fbpx
Log in

Login to your account

Username *
Password *
Remember Me

Create an account

Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.
Name *
Username *
Password *
Verify password *
Email *
Verify email *
Captcha *

UK benefits restriction could hit 120,000 Portuguese

davidcameronAbout 120,000 Portuguese emigrants to the UK may be affected by the British Prime Minister’s proposal to cut social support to European Union immigrants.

"According to the Emigration Observatory data, in 2013 and 2014 about 30,000 Portuguese entered the UK each year. This number did not change substantially in 2015 and will not change in 2016 and 2017. This points to about 120,000 Portuguese being affected," says Portugal’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

At issue is one of the four conditions put up by David Cameron in his renegotiation of the relationship of the UK with Brussels, prior to a referendum being held on whether to the UK stays part of the EC, or leaves.

In the proposal, Cameron wants Brussels to give the go-ahead to restrict European immigrants’ access to social benefits in the first four years of living in the UK.

Margarida Marquês, Portugal's Secretary of State for European Affairs, commented, "what the UK is proposing in terms of immigration policy does not respect the principle of non-discrimination and this we cannot accept."

The Portuguese reaction was replicated in most countries which export their citizens to the UK in significant numbers. Unsurprisingly, the greatest resistance came from Poland which has 700,000 of its citizens living in the UK.

In a tentative agreement at the end of 2015, France and Germany’s governments said they are willing to accept a suspension of social benefits, but only for a period of three years.

This proposal was well received by the British, "The UK is open to compromise and Cameron has the impression that many European leaders are also ready for it," said a French diplomat.

Pin It

Comments  

-4 #13 Tom P 2016-01-11 22:31
"Tom P massively overstates the actual number of benefits available, and fails utterly to point out that there are many qualifying conditions that must be met before anyone obtains any benefit at all. It's not simply a case of being in the country!"

I was outlining the range of benefits available for those in the UK system. All are available for qualifying residents. Cameron is proposing restrictions for recent immigrants, many of who currently are entitled to a range of the above - not all of them, obviously.
Tom
0 #12 JJ in Gibraltar 2016-01-11 20:52
Quoting Mike Towl:
Tom P's contribution is interesting, God knows what benefits a working age Brit is entitled to over here, very few I would imagine. Maybe Dave could himself be imaginative and propose treating each EU country individually and pay their nationals only what their government pay immigrant Brits. Seems fair.


Tom P massively overstates the actual number of benefits available, and fails utterly to point out that there are many qualifying conditions that must be met before anyone obtains any benefit at all. It's not simply a case of being in the country!

There's no chance of Dave being imaginative (he's a Tory for crying out loud - greed rules all!).
-6 #11 Mike Towl 2016-01-09 08:26
Tom P's contribution is interesting, God knows what benefits a working age Brit is entitled to over here, very few I would imagine. Maybe Dave could himself be imaginative and propose treating each EU country individually and pay their nationals only what their government pay immigrant Brits. Seems fair.
0 #10 JJ in Gibraltar 2016-01-08 22:00
And this latest news should start the UKippers on here frothing at the mouth!

http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/jan/08/david-cameron-eu-renegotiation-could-extend-four-year-tax-credits-ban-british-expats
0 #9 JJ in Gibraltar 2016-01-08 16:16
Quoting chiptheduck:
I don't expect the Portuguese taxpayer to provide me with benefits. [blah blah]

The EU are providing a charter for idle Europeans to flock to the country offering the highest benefits. Which is why France built Sangat and is now creating an even larger camp on the Channel coast.


I'm afraid you flaunt your complete ignorance when you talk of Sangatte.

As you most likely use some form of computer, please note computers these days usually have access to something called Wikipedia, which may help you out should you wish to learn, to know (and later maybe even to speak?) the truth.

Also note that whether you like it or not, should you ever need a Portuguese benefit you will have access to it provided you meet the relevant qualifying conditions (i.e., same as a Portuguese citizen in the UK).

And thank you Ed for highlighting "as is their right".
-1 #8 dw 2016-01-08 16:00
Cameron will take any opportunity available to dismantle social security, along with the NHS while spending billions on bombing Syria.
0 #7 algarveandroid 2016-01-08 15:49
Now I wonder how many expats are double footing , over my many years here I have seen many instances of vocal brits , some with council houses back in the uk where they go back for medical treatment costing thousands , yet are driving illegal uk cars. Ironically these seem to be the most vocal regarding uk immigration , but are all too happy when their doctor is an immigrant , yet dont put their principals to practice and refuse to be treated by anyone but a British educated doctor.

The problem is not immigration , a cheap and cheerful blame hound for society , directed by the wealthy elite , politician and media , the problem is though like a good magician to divert the gaze away from the true problems , lack of investment in training and turnign the hatred that should be for the elite and banker towards an easier scapegoat.
-3 #6 chiptheduck 2016-01-08 12:03
I don't expect the Portuguese taxpayer to provide me with benefits. Reciprocal emergency health treatment is fine, but those moving to other countries should be able to support themselves day to day, not act as parasites.

The EU are providing a charter for idle Europeans to flock to the country offering the highest benefits. Which is why France built Sangat and is now creating an even larger camp on the Channel coast.
-2 #5 Ed 2016-01-08 09:47
Quoting Peter Booker:

As other correspondents have shown, EU immigrants in the UK are there to work.
It is not just unemployment benefits that Cameron wants to limit. These benefits form only a part of the comprehensive UK social safety blanket of which many take full advantage, as it their right. The low paid in the UK, of which the Portuguese surely form a part, also would be affected by a cut in 'social support' benefits.
+1 #4 Tom P 2016-01-08 09:41
Margaret: UK Benefits include: Carer's Credit,Child Benefit for children in hospital or care,Child Benefit if a child or parent dies,Child Benefit if you leave the UK,Child Benefit if you move to the UK,Child Benefit if your child lives with someone else,Child Tax Credit,Childcare vouchers,Christmas Bonus,Cold Weather Payment,Constant Attendance Allowance,Council Tax Reduction,Diffuse mesothelioma payments,Disability premiums (Income Support),Employment and Support Allowance,Free or discounted TV licence,Help with moving from benefits to work,Housing Benefit,In Work Credit,Income Support,Industrial Injuries Disablement Benefit,Job Grant,Jobseeker's Allowance,Mortgage Interest Run On,National Concessionary Fuel Scheme,Pension Credit,Prescription prepayment certificates,Reduced Earnings Allowance,Return to Work Credit,Support for Mortgage Interest,Tax credits if you have a baby,Tax credits if you leave or move to the UK,Warm Home Discount Scheme,Winter Fuel Payment,Working Tax Credit,Bereavement Allowance,Bereavement Payment,Child Benefit if a child or parent dies,Childcare grant,Council Tax Reduction,Disability Benefits Centre,Disability Living Allowance for adults,Disability Living Allowance for children,Disability premiums,Disabled Facilities Grants,Disabled Students' Allowances,Employment and Support Allowance,Financial help is there has been a fire,Funeral Payments,Guardian's Allowance,Help paying for childcare,Maternity Allowance,Maternity pay and leave,Parents' Learning Allowance,Pension credit,Sure Start Maternity Grant,Universal credit,Widowed Parent's Allowance

You must be a registered user to make comments.
Please register here to post your comments.