Parliament on Thursday, 19 November, confirmed approval of a Chega party proposal to guarantee that RTP, Portugal’s state-funded broadcasting, returns to televising bullfighting events. The Socialist Party (PS) switched its vote from abstention to opposition, and the decision followed a fiery debate.
The proposal, approved in committee the day before, was called to the floor for scrutiny by PAN. It survived with votes in favour from the PSD, CDS-PP, and Chega, and against from all the other benches. The only change from Wednesday came from the Socialist Party, which abstained in committee but chose on Thursday to vote against.
Tempers ran so high that deputy speaker Rodrigo Saraiva, who was chairing the session, had to step in. He asked MPs not to turn the chamber “into a bullfight”, asking those present to lower their voices and defuse tensions.
The left called the proposal a “civilisational step backwards” and an “attempt at political interference”. The CDS-PP countered by invoking “cultural freedom”.
PAN’s sole MP, Inês Sousa Real, said the measure was not only “a regrettable civilisational step backwards” but “a direct affront to the television law itself”. She argued it violates “the commitment RTP has made to animal welfare” and asked the PSD “how it can allow such an affront”.
The vote, she said, “smells of the Estado Novo”, the authoritarian regime that governed Portugal until the Carnation Revolution of 1974. She warned that “civil society will not accept this retreat”, claiming “more than 70% of Portuguese people do not want bullfighting”. She also urged the PS to change its vote to against, which it did.
Her speech caused some commotion and several heckles.
Socialist Porfírio Silva said the debate was “a question of freedom”. He warned that parliament “should avoid trying to take RTP’s place” and called for an end to “attempts at political interference in the media”.
Bloco de Esquerda’s (Left Bloc) sole MP, Fabian Figueiredo, lamented that, “in the midst of the most significant housing crisis”, it was bullfight broadcasts that had united the PSD, CDS, and Chega. Criticising possible political meddling, he said that “if the fashion catches on”, politicians would soon “dictate to private channels what they must broadcast”. “When press freedom starts to be curtailed, it starts with the public channel,” he added.
From the right, CDS-PP’s Paulo Núncio declared that “yesterday [Wednesday] cultural freedom won”. He insisted that “bullfighting is culture, is recognised as culture and is protected by law”, adding that RTP cannot discriminate culturally. “We will not bow to the dictatorship of taste that some would like to impose on us,” he said.
Iniciativa Liberal’s (Liberal Initiative) Carlos Guimarães Pinto lamented that the topic stirring the most interest at the committee stage was RTP showing bullfights. “If we’re going to get nostalgic for the old TV schedule, please be more ambitious next year. Why only bullfights?” he quipped, calling for the return of Rua Sésamo (the Portuguese Sesame Street), Vitinho, and Jogos Sem Fronteiras (the Portuguese version of gameshow It’s a Knockout).
For the JPP party, Filipe Sousa said bullfighting “is a matter that divides opinion” and that RTP “should give priority to information, education and content that serve the true national public interest”. “Respect for tradition does not oblige us to agree with every practice, much less to fund its broadcast through our public television service,” he opined.
Source: LUSA / CNN Portugal
Photo credit: Eduardo Leal









